Why did a two-story fire station at Mile Marker 17 have to wait on a cell tower lease signed in 2014?
Last month the old Station 10 at 17175 Overseas Highway started coming down. Monroe County then scheduled a ceremonial groundbreaking at the site for Monday, Nov. 16, at 2 p.m. and invited the community. The plans call for an 8,320-square-foot building. They also include a multipurpose room that the county says was added "at the community's request." That room is the oldest part of the project. Sugarloaf residents asked for a meeting hall on this lot years ago, and for most of the time since, the lot couldn't hold both the hall and the tower already promised there.
A Small Lot With Three Claims On It
The station was never county property. It belonged to the Sugarloaf Volunteer Fire Department, Inc. The volunteers go back a long way here. The State Archives of Florida holds a photo of a Sugarloaf Volunteer Fire Department tanker parked outside its station, dated around 1975.
The trouble started in November 2014. According to the Key West Citizen, the volunteer department signed an agreement that month with Sugarloaf Wi-Fi Inc., a local cell tower company. The deal gave the company space on the property for a tower and equipment, and it was renewed on Nov. 13, 2016. Meanwhile, the county and Sugarloaf residents wanted to replace the aging station with a new one.
The Citizen quoted Jim Callahan, then the Monroe County fire chief, on why the lot was stuck. He said the property didn't have room for the tower and its equipment plus a new station with a meeting hall, "which is something Sugarloaf residents have requested." The paper also reported that the county would need an easement from the Florida Department of Transportation just to fit the station and the meeting room.
So three parties had claims on one parcel: a volunteer group that owned it, a tower company holding a lease, and a county that wanted to rebuild it. It took two court cases to settle.
From Lease to Groundbreaking
County agenda packets record each step. Here is the order:
| Date | What happened at 17175 Overseas Highway |
|---|---|
| Nov. 4, 2014 | Volunteer department and Sugarloaf Wi-Fi sign tower-space agreement |
| Nov. 13, 2016 | Agreement renewed |
| July 19, 2017 | County Commission authorizes a suit to void the lease |
| Nov. 22, 2021 | Consent judgment entered against the volunteer department in the county's case |
| April 20, 2022 | Commission deems Fortress Secured's unsolicited proposal a "qualifying project" |
| March 6, 2023 | Interim agreement with Fortress takes effect |
| July 17, 2024 | Commission approves the comprehensive agreement |
| Sept. 4, 2024 | Settlement among county, volunteers and Sugarloaf Wi-Fi ratified |
| July 2025 | Crews leave the station for a temporary site on Sugarloaf |
| July 29, 2026 | Crews begin responding from Big Coppitt and Cudjoe stations |
| Late October 2026 | Demolition begins |
| Nov. 16, 2026 | Ceremonial groundbreaking scheduled |
| Early 2028 | Expected completion |
The longest gap in that table runs from July 2017 to November 2021, and in those years the plan changed direction. According to the county's July 17, 2024 agenda item, the volunteer department told the county during the litigation that it could no longer provide firefighting services. It offered to donate the station so Monroe County Fire Rescue could keep serving Sugarloaf.
The Builder Arrived Uninvited, and Paid Its Own Way to the Table
In April 2022 a company called Fortress Secured, LLC sent the county a proposal it hadn't asked for. Fortress offered to design and build a replacement station under Florida's public-private partnership statute. Its plan assumed the county would take ownership from the volunteers first. The proposal also left space on the property for a cell tower. That gave the county a way out of the tower dispute instead of another fight over it.
The county advertised the project and asked for competing proposals. None came in. Under the interim agreement, Fortress handled the design plans, construction budget and schedule, and it covered those costs itself. The county's agenda says it "received no compensation under the interim agreement." In July 2024 the county held a public hearing so residents and public agencies could comment on the draft agreement. No comments were submitted. The next day, July 17, 2024, the commission approved the agreement. The agenda backup put the agreement's total value at $9,610,275 at the time of that vote.
Ten Dollars and 720 Square Feet
The settlement, ratified on Sept. 4, 2024, ended the dispute over who could use the lot. The volunteer department agreed to convey the property to the county for $10.00, plus the county's satisfaction of the 2021 consent judgment. Sugarloaf Wi-Fi kept the chance to develop a communications tower on the site.
The tower's share of the lot was set at about 720 square feet. That figure comes from the county's August 2024 agenda describing the new county lease with Sugarloaf Wi-Fi for a cellular communications tower at Station 10. The county also agreed to sign that lease even if the Fortress project never went ahead. Once the tower's space was fixed and the county owned the land, the station and the meeting room could be designed around it.
What Goes Up at Mile Marker 17
According to Keys Weekly, the county decided the old station had structural and maintenance problems that made it "no longer economically repairable." Crews had already left it. In July 2025, Station 10 personnel moved to a temporary location on Sugarloaf Key after the building was found unsuitable for occupancy.
The new building is two stories and 8,320 square feet. Monroe County Facilities Development and Monroe County Fire Rescue are running the project together. The multipurpose room is part of the official plans. "At the community's request" is how KONK Life and the county describe it. That's the meeting hall residents asked for when the Citizen was covering the tower dispute.
"The new Sugarloaf Key fire station represents Monroe County's continued investment in public safety infrastructure," Fire Chief R.L. Colina told Keys Weekly.
The schedule has shifted in both directions this fall. In October, local outlets expected a groundbreaking in early December and completion around the end of 2027. The county later moved the ceremony up to Nov. 16. Its event notice now gives early 2028 for completion.
Who Answers Sugarloaf Calls Until Then
Since July 29, 2026, Station 10 crews have responded from Station 9 on Big Coppitt Key and Station 11 on Cudjoe Key. Monroe County Fire Rescue says Sugarloaf keeps a dedicated Advanced Life Support response capability, staffed by county firefighters and paramedics on their usual shifts. The county's July 30 announcement adds that Station 10 crews still do their daily training, fire inspections and pre-incident planning on Sugarloaf Key. It also says the department will watch response times and adjust if needed.
The station was never a polling place, so voting isn't affected. The Monroe County Supervisor of Elections lists Sugarloaf precincts 13 and 14 at Sugarloaf Baptist Church, 260 Crane Blvd.
Dates on the Sugarloaf Calendar While the Lot Stays Fenced
The new hall won't be ready for the 2026–27 winter season. A few dated events are still on the calendar a few miles from the construction site:
- Through Dec. 31, 2026: The Sugarloaf Key/Key West KOA at 251 County Road 939 lists live music in its pub on Tuesday and weekend evenings, and says the pub is open to the public.
- Nov. 26, 2026: The KOA lists a Thanksgiving potluck.
- Dec. 31, 2026: The KOA lists a New Year's Eve party.
- Feb. 26, 2027: The Florida Keys Poker Run, Ride for the Kids, is listed at the KOA.
- Early 2028: The county's expected completion date for Station 10 and its multipurpose room.
The Lower Keys has watched this lot for more than a decade, and we've followed every turn of the Station 10 story from our office on Big Pine Key. If you'd like to know how the rebuild at Mile Marker 17 fits into the Sugarloaf Key you know, The Karen Haack Team is glad to talk it through. Talk to a Lower Keys real estate expert today.