Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Sunlit teal canal and mangroves seen from an airy coastal living room with an ivory sofa and warm wood furnishings.

Big Pine Key Vacation Rental Income, Read Month by Month

November 19, 2026

In fiscal 2026, Monroe County collected $5,384,771.05 in four-penny tourist tax from the district that includes Big Pine Key. That was 1.9 percent more than the year before. On its own, that annual figure tells a rental buyer very little. Of that $5.38 million, 38 percent came in during January, February and March. September, the slowest month, brought in less than a third of what March did. A Big Pine Key vacation home earns its money on that calendar, so a projection built on a yearly average will misread it in both directions.

The Monroe County Tourist Development Council published the full-year figures on November 6, 2026, in its Four Penny Revenue Report covering bed tax "through September 30, 2026." The tax applies to hotel rooms and vacation rentals, as Keys Weekly has reported. The council reports those collections district by district, month by month.

The Lower Keys Year, Month by Month

These are District II's collections for fiscal 2026, which ran from October 2025 through September 2026, along with each month's change from fiscal 2025.

Month FY2026 collections Change from FY2025
October 2025 $256,504 +14.9%
November 2025 $365,150 +12.4%
December 2025 $526,176 -1.5%
January 2026 $693,694 +9.6%
February 2026 $679,254 +6.4%
March 2026 $694,839 +0.5%
April 2026 $511,101 -8.4%
May 2026 $422,863 +3.2%
June 2026 $363,834 -5.3%
July 2026 $405,398 +2.7%
August 2026 $269,375 -14.1%
September 2026 $196,584 +8.7%

January through March added up to about $2.07 million, roughly 38 percent of the year. Widen the window to December through April and the share rises to about 58 percent. August and September together came to about 9 percent. March, the top month, collected about 3.5 times what September did.

July is the one summer month that rises above the months around it, at $405,398. That puts it ahead of June and well ahead of August, but it still came in at about 58 percent of a January.

What District II Counts

Visit Florida Keys calls the advisory committee for District II "Big Pine & Lower Keys," but the district reaches well past Big Pine. It begins at the edge of Key West and runs up to the Seven Mile Bridge, taking in Stock Island, Key Haven, Sugarloaf Key, Cudjoe Key, Summerland Key, the Torch Keys, Big Pine Key and Bahia Honda.

So the district total includes hotel rooms that have nothing to do with a canal home on Big Pine. On Stock Island, The Perry Hotel & Marina is a 100-room property that took its first guests on May 1, 2017. Key International announced it had bought the hotel on March 31, 2023. Nearby is the 175-room Ocean's Edge Resort & Marina, owned by Sunstone Hotel Investors, which Hilton has announced as Hilton Key West Resort & Marina in its Florida Keys expansion.

Farther up the highway, the district also includes Sugarloaf Lodge, a 31-room property at mile marker 17, and the Sugarloaf Key/Key West KOA, which has RV and tent sites and an all-suite hotel. On Little Torch Key it includes Parmer's Resort, with cottages, suites, studios and rooms on five acres, and Little Palm Island sits just offshore. Bahia Honda State Park's cabins and campgrounds are inside the district too.

On Big Pine itself, the old Big Pine Key Fishing Lodge now operates as Cove's Big Pine Key Resort, with RV sites, tent camping and trailer rentals. Its 2026 construction notice says a 12-week pool and recreation-center project is underway, with both amenities closed while the work goes on.

Because the district blends resort hotels, a campground hotel, state park cabins and private vacation homes into one figure, it shows when visitors come to the Lower Keys. It does not show how full any one Big Pine home was. The calendar is what carries over to a single rental. The dollar totals do not.

Where This Year's 1.9 Percent Came From

The net gain for fiscal 2026 was $98,916. Most of it came early in the fiscal year. October rose $33,351, November rose $40,200, January rose $60,810 and February rose $41,022. Those four months alone added about $175,000.

Later in the year the district gave some of that back. April fell $47,119, June fell $20,176 and August fell $44,182, and December slipped $8,281. March, the biggest month, was nearly flat at plus 0.5 percent. Its top-month number held, but it did not grow.

In the Lower Keys, fall and early winter were stronger, the peak held level, and spring and late summer were softer. For a rental owner, the weeks just before and after the core of season are where the year improved, and they are also the weeks a pricing calendar sets most loosely.

The other districts help put the 1.9 percent in context. In fiscal 2026, District I, which is the City of Key West, collected $29,492,421.24, up 2.5 percent. District III, from the west end of the Seven Mile Bridge to the Long Key Bridge, rose 2.1 percent. District IV, from the Long Key Bridge to mile marker 90.939, rose 8.3 percent. Countywide collections came to $63,176,203.53. The Lower Keys grew a little more slowly than Key West and Marathon this year.

September closed on a stronger note everywhere. District II rose 8.7 percent that month, and the county as a whole rose 14.9 percent.

A Decade of the Lower Keys Share

Over a longer period the trend is clearer. District II collected $2,004,925.89 in fiscal 2016 and $5,384,771.05 in fiscal 2026, about 2.7 times as much. Its share of the county's bed tax rose from 5.46 percent to 8.52 percent over the same years.

The path had two breaks. Fiscal 2018, the year that began just after Hurricane Irma in September 2017, fell 16.8 percent. Fiscal 2021 jumped 83.8 percent to $4,669,268.34. In June 2021, Keys Weekly reported that Keys hoteliers tied that spring's demand to pandemic-era travel shifts, including less overseas travel and cruising. The Perry had opened on Stock Island in 2017, so part of the long-term rise reflects new hotel rooms at the Key West end of the district.

From fiscal 2022 through fiscal 2026, District II has held between about $5.0 million and $5.5 million a year, and its county share has stayed between 7.98 and 8.59 percent. The Lower Keys moved up to a higher level after 2021 and have stayed there. Fiscal 2026 was a steady year at that level, with no new surge.

What Countywide Rental Data Adds

The Tourist Development Council also reports vacation-rental performance, but only for the county as a whole. Those figures show the same seasonal shape at the level of a rental unit. In July 2026, adjusted short-term rental occupancy across the Keys was 45.8 percent at an average daily rate of $476. By September 2026, occupancy was 23.5 percent at $380.47, which was still up 11.0 percent and 13.3 percent from the previous September.

The council's weekly snapshot dated October 12, 2026, showed $15.8 million in Keys vacation-rental revenue already on the books for October through December, 7.7 percent ahead of the same point a year earlier. October has since passed, so the part of that figure still ahead covers late November and December, the month when Lower Keys collections start climbing toward the January peak. In fiscal 2025, 16 percent of Keys visitors stayed in short-term vacation rentals.

Reading a Big Pine Rental Projection Against This Calendar

Put the ledger next to a seller's or manager's income figures and a few questions follow. How much of the home's gross came from January through March? If it is far below the district's 38 percent, either the home earns well outside season or the winter rates were set too low. If it is far above, the home depends heavily on one quarter, and a soft March would cost it more than an average would suggest.

Ask for monthly history, not one annual total. This year the Lower Keys gained in October, November and September and lost ground in April and August. A home's month-by-month record shows whether it followed that pattern or did better than it. Because the Stock Island hotels sit inside the same district number, a Big Pine canal home's own calendar is the better evidence. Whether a particular Big Pine property can rent nightly at all depends on the property, so ask us about it before any income figure goes into an offer.

This is general market information, not financial or tax advice. Before relying on any income projection, confirm your situation with your accountant or financial advisor.

A Few Questions Buyers Ask First

When does the Tourist Development Council update these figures? The current Four Penny Revenue Report covers bed tax through September 30, 2026, and is dated November 6, 2026. The council posts the reports on visitfloridakeys.com as each month's collections come in.

Is District II the same as Big Pine Key? District II is larger. It stretches from Stock Island to the Seven Mile Bridge, and Big Pine is one part of it.

Which month was slowest in the Lower Keys in fiscal 2026? September, at $196,583.55. That was still up 8.7 percent from September 2025.

The Karen Haack Team is based on Big Pine Key and runs vacation-rental management alongside sales. If you are weighing a rental purchase this season, we can go through a home's month-by-month record with you before you make an offer. Talk to a Lower Keys real estate expert today.

Follow Us On Instagram